Site Map | Contact
 
Skip Navigation Links
September 2007
 
In this Issue

Two recent events are at the center of this issue of Paths to Peoplehood. The first is the 2007 Conference on the Future of the Jewish People, sponsored by the Jewish People Policy Planning Institute (JPPPI), which convened during June in Jerusalem. We begin the discussion of the conference with a summary of sorts taken from The Jewish Standard and continue with various evaluations and critiques of the conference: Jerusalem Post writers debate whether too much time was devoted to Israeli national security. Rachel Fish and Tamar Fox offer opposing opinions on the question of the connection of the younger generation to Jewish Peoplehood while Jonathan Rosenblum asks why there were no Haredim at the conference. Fox's explanation why she is not making aliya, leads us to Einat Wilf's suggestion that as a result of globalization it is no longer necessary to have permanent residence in Israel in order to maintain a strong connection, and that Zionist organizations should consider alternatives to aliya.

The second issue discussed in this edition is that of intermarriage. Defining boundaries is of critical importance for any People that wishes to survive; the issue of intermarriage is the central locus for Diaspora Jewry's boundary drawing. Long seen as a 'problem' only for the liberal denominations, Noah Feldman, a graduate of a modern-Orthodox yeshiva high school who is now married to a non-Jewish woman, brought the issue of Orthodoxy's attitude towards intermarriage to the forefront. Feldman describes in a NYT's article how he has been ostracized by his alma mater, he explains this reaction as well as his own life choices as a result of what he calls the "Orthodox Paradox". Many American Orthodox Jews experienced Feldman's article as an attack upon their values and responded in kind. We bring here an example of such a reaction by Sultan Knish as well as a moderate Orthodox response by Shmuley Boteach, a view from a non-Orthodox perspective by Ami Eden and an overview by Yair Sheleg.

We close this issue with HUC's president David Ellenson's call to enhance Jewish Peoplehood by fostering closer relations between Israeli and Diaspora Jews in a presentation given at the 2007 Herzliya conference.

In the wake of the Conference on the Future of the Jewish People:
The goal of the JPPPI conference was to plan the future of the Jewish people; here is a summary of suggestions and resolutions.
Should there have been different issues on the conference agenda?
Some writers claim that conference devoted too much of its time to national security issues, and not enough to social and educational issues.
Who was missing from the conference?
Young conference participants claim that there is a chasm between youth and Jewish leadership. J. Rosenblum discusses the absence of Haredim from the conference.
Peoplehood and Aliya:
T. Fox explains the reasons behind her choice not to live in Israel, and E. Wilf suggests a new Zionist policy for a global age.
Intermarriage - the storm raised by Noah Feldman's NYT article:
Noah Feldman admonishes the Orthodox community for their lack of acceptance of his gentile wife. We bring in this section the original article as well a variety of reactions.
On Peoplehood:
Rabbi Prof. David Ellenson, President, Hebrew Union College lays out his view on the current state of Israeli and American Jewry and the direction they should be taking.


Edited by Ari Engelberg
Graphics and presentation by Keren Elkayam
Top





Register 
Print this page
In This Issue (editorial) - September 2007
Future of the Jewish People
Conference agenda
Who was missing
Peoplehood and Aliya
Intermarriage
On Peoplehood